The Rectory

A loft-style coach house that once served as a church rectory, tucked into Lincoln Park.

Why we picked itA church rectory turned guesthouse, hosted by the man who converted the church next door.

David bought a church, converted it, and lived in its detached rectory while the main house was being redone. Now the rectory is a two-bedroom guesthouse with lofted ceilings and a fireplace.

It sleeps seven, with a king loft suite upstairs and a bunk room below. There's a basketball court on site. David has hosted for 12 years and is an Airbnb Superhost with 600+ reviews.